California’s “up the ante” on energy efficiency savings needs new capital market money to make it happen. California consumers as ratepayers and taxpayers cannot afford the billions to achieve CA’s new efficiency legislation.
California needs new banking and institutional capital transaction structures that match investment and to long term efficiency yield, and, creating long term net income streams as efficiency is capitalized equivalent to generation, transmission, distribution.
California is at a critical juncture: chart the described new course, or continue to game energy efficiency accomplishments. Read my 2-pg OP piece.
September 2015. NRDC Misleading Regarding California’s Energy Efficiency Success Story.
NRDC’s new report, California’s Golden Energy Efficiency Opportunity: Ramping Up Success to Save Billions and Meet Climate Goals, is a rehash of prior , and teeing up of some nes, overstated claims of California’s energy efficiency success story.
For over a decade, the Golden State has claimed to be a, if not the, national and international leader in saving energy. Such folklore wouldn’t be so bad if it stayed in California. But California’s “energy efficiency success story” is the under girdle of state and national energy policies, and hand-carried to the likes of China as the “how to” primer on reducing electric carbon emissions.
The truth is, while California has accomplished a great deal in saving energy, but not to the scale and scope represented by NRDC claims in its recently released report “California Energy Efficiency Opportunity: Ramping Up Success to Save Billions and Meet Climate Goals”. Clinging to an overstated glory has resulted in a huge Rube Goldberg construct of complex and convoluted utility-run, ratepayer funded efficiency programs that dance to the rhythm of two steps forward – one or two steps back on energy savings and cost efficiencies.
The opportunities and challenges ahead are tremendous, calling for structural shifts in CA’s regulatory approach to energy efficiency. NRDC would have regulators stay largely with the status quo, reasoning that it will get CA where it needs to go. I appreciate NRDC’s commitment to CA energy efficiency, and have a different perspective on CA’s energy efficiency success story. My November 2014 Electricity Policy article CA EE Manifesto lays this out.
If Governor Brown’s 2015 Inaugural 50-50-50 goals (reduce transportation fuel use by 50%, increase renewables to 50% of electric generation, and make buildings 50% more energy efficient) – has a chance in hell, California will have to (at least with building efficiency), do something radically different.
It begins in part with deconstructing the current Rube Goldberg construct of complex and convoluted efficiency programs through some fairly basic changes, in tandem with new market-based approaches to financing efficiency through the large capital markets.
- Cumulative savings are at best about one-half of what NRDC claims, meaning that far fewer than 30 power plants have been avoided via EE, and, EE savings are short of the 2020 AB 32 GHG target.
- EE costs are close to, if not more than, the cost of equivalent energy and capacity.
Follow the link to The Utility Reform Network’s media response to the NRDC report.
NRDC and E2 Report – TURN-Media-Rxn
July 2015. Governor’s Brown’s New Efficiency Goals
CMitchell_TURN_CEC_Gov’s_EE_Goals_July_6_2015
CMitchell_TURN_Comments_July_6_2015
“TURN CEC Gov’s EE Goals” is shorthand for “The Utility Reform Network (my client –the largest, oldest, and most dedicated consumer advocate office in the country — what a privledge and pleasure to work with TURN as their efficiency expert!) “CEC” is the California Energy Commission. This was a recent proceeding regarding Governor’s Brown’s 2015 goal of 50% improvement in building efficiency. My ppt and text attached. Nice picture of my girls (hens) basket of eggs toward ppt end.
November 2014. “California Energy Efficiency Manifesto”
Mitchell_EE_Manifesto_11_17_2014
“Mitchell EE Manifesto” is shorthand for my November 2014 Electricity Policy article “A New Energy Efficiency Manifesto: California Needs a More Integrated Cost-Effective Approah”. In many ways this sums up my 15 years of California work with all the stops pulled out. I am forever grateful to and for Robert Marritz, editor and publisher for his tremendous work on this piece.