Mid-May I zoom debated a representative from the American Gas Association (AGA) on the role of natural gas in the clean energy economy. In preparation I did a massive deep dive into the issue. What I found was so startling in its clarity that I dubbed my talk It’s the Methane…(Stupid!), or The “Bridge Fuel” is a Highway to Hell. Turns out that in the past ten years, there has been a sharp rise in atmospheric methane concentrations. It is well documented that methane accounts for about 25% of the warming causing climate change, with natural gas responsible for a large portion. Because methane is 80-plus times more potent than carbon dioxide in heating up the earth’s atmosphere, and short-lived (20 years vs. 100), methane today plays a disproportionate role in the climate emergency, and in the solutions.

And nowhere in the country is methane a bigger issue than in this region. A recent Santa Fe New Mexican lead article reported on a study by an environmental group and eco-conscious investor network that found oil and gas operators in New Mexico to be emitting a disproportionate amount of methane. Some of the releases are unreported and unlawful.  The article quotes an EPA spokesperson as saying that voluntary emission reductions are not enough to solve the widespread compliance issues in the San Juan and Permian Basins. 

Right there is a relatively straightforward way to buy some much-needed time to cool the planet. Methane is short-lived. The atmosphere responds quickly to changes in methane emissions. Reducing methane now can provide an instant way to slow global warming by up to 30%. 

In other words, we turned up the global heat fast with methane, and we can turn it down, quickly, by reducing fracking and gas use.

The biggest, fastest, bang for the buck in reducing gas use is phasing out gas-fired power generation, which accounts for nearly 40% of all domestic gas use. Continued progress in the technology of harvesting wind and solar energy, coupled with advances in battery storage, are now eclipsing gas generation in terms of cost and performance. 

What killed coal was not the environment, but the economics of improved technology in gas extraction and gas power plants. Now gas generation is in the equivalent position: the price of renewable energy plus storage is approaching the operating cost of new gas generation. 

I approached the debate at the caliber of an expert witness. 

The AGA rep had hardly bothered to prepare. At first I was disappointed, even angry, then saddened and depressed. It felt like my debate performance didn’t much matter. She was just a placeholder, a cardboard cutout used by the fossil fuel industry as a roadblock to meaningful dialogue. AGA powder puff to my pro bowl. They save their big guns for the halls of Congress, and state and local legislators and government officials. Fossil fuels make the world go round, with money in the chase. 

The debate did give me a chance to rub shoulders with several old and new colleagues, affirming the importance of human connection. My darling niece, a PhD environmental engineer with the EPA who is knowledgeable on greenhouse gases, was a big help during my debate preparation. Afterwards, she said that I had done a good job of presenting consensus solutions while stressing the urgency of the issue. If so, it’s only because she got me there. Others said that even though the AGA rep didn’t stand a chance against me, my kindness toward her and empathy for the industry’s position came through.  That’s what I wanted out of the debate. To completely nail it while being fiercely compassionate.

You can find the video recording of the debate at this link: https://www.cleantechalliance.org/debates-at-kl-gates-series/. My written comments with all references are posted on Linkedin.

I would love to hear from you! What are your thoughts about the climate crisis? 

How is it affecting you? Do you feel helpless or empowered? Do you make any conscious choices, day by day, that might help? What are they? Have you considered becoming involved in the struggle? How?

Subscribe

Subscribe

Join my mailing list to receive the latest news and publication updates.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This